There’s usually someone in every industry who seems to be everywhere. On the conference stage, in your LinkedIn feed, appearing on a podcast you’ve been meaning to listen to. Familiar enough that you feel you know them, even if you’ve never actually spoken.
That familiarity can be very persuasive, particularly when you’re a brand looking for someone to help you reach the right people. But being visible and being influential aren’t necessarily the same thing. Someone can be very good at getting attention without having much influence over what anyone thinks, believes or buys.
That distinction really matters. You’re asking someone to bring their experience, judgement and relationships to a conversation in which your business has a commercial interest. Their credibility makes up a large part of what you’re investing in.
So, before you get too distracted by the follower count, it’s worth asking four fairly straightforward questions. Read on for our B2B Influencer Checklist.
Expertise: Does this influencer actually know the subject?
We’ve probably all read a post that sounds convincing until we get to the end and realise it hasn’t actually told us anything. Confident language, a topical reference, perhaps a prediction about the future. But very little that helps us understand the subject any better.
In B2B, the detail matters. The people you want to reach may work with these challenges every day. They’re likely to recognise the difference between someone who understands the complexities and someone who has just learnt the vocabulary.
Look for experience that gives their opinions some substance. That might be a current or previous industry role, technical qualifications, or published work.
Also, look at how they handle the things they don’t know. Someone who can explain the limits of their experience, or acknowledge where an issue is complicated, can be much more convincing than someone with a definitive answer to absolutely everything.
Your expertise checklist:
‣ Do they have demonstrable experience in your sector, or the problem your campaign addresses?
‣ Can you verify the credentials behind their profile?
‣ Do credible peers engage with, reference or challenge their thinking?
‣ Are their opinions specific, considered, and supported by examples?
A useful question to ask yourself is whether you would still value their advice if you couldn’t see how many followers they had.
Audience: Are the right people listening to your influencer?
A room full of people is only useful if it contains the people you need to speak to. It sounds obvious, but it’s surprisingly easy to forget when a large audience is attached to an impressive-looking profile. Reach is reassuring. It gives us a number to put in a presentation. But understanding who makes up that number takes a little more work.
Make sure you figure out the people you want to influence. Which industries do they work in? What responsibilities do they have? Where are they based? And who else contributes to the decisions you want to affect?
The most relevant audience won’t necessarily be the biggest, or consist entirely of people who would be the ones signing the contracts. Technical specialists, advisers, and future decision-makers may all have a part to play. Remember to look beyond the volume of engagement to the quality of the conversation. Are people asking thoughtful questions? Sharing their own experiences? Disagreeing in ways that suggest they’ve actually read the post? If so, it sounds like your potential influencer is doing things right.
Your audience checklist:
‣ Does their audience match the roles, sectors and geographies you need to reach?
‣ Does engagement come from identifiable, relevant professionals?
‣ Do comments show discussion, questions and an exchange of experience?
‣ Does audience growth look plausible, with any unusual spikes explained? (A sudden increase in followers might follow a successful event or a widely shared piece of work. It’s a reason to ask a question, rather than jump to a conclusion.)
Content: will your message belong here?
Imagine following someone because they make a difficult subject interesting, only to find their next post reads like a product brochure. You’d notice, and so would their audience.
An influencer’s value is partly in the way they communicate. Their perspective, their choice of subjects, their ability to explain something that other people make unnecessarily complicated. If a partnership removes all of that, it risks removing the reason people listened in the first place.
Look through their content over time. Does it consistently offer something useful? Can they sustain an argument beyond an opening hook? Have they found formats that suit both their expertise and their audience?
Then consider what you actually want the partnership to achieve. A short video might introduce an idea effectively, then a newsletter, webinar or podcast might give a more complicated subject the space it needs.
Your content checklist:
‣ Do they publish with enough consistency to maintain an active relationship with their audience?
‣ Does their content teach, explain or offer a worthwhile perspective?
‣ Are their strongest formats suited to your subject and campaign objectives?
‣ Is previous sponsored content clearly identified and credible alongside their other work? (Pay particular attention to that last point. A good partnership should give the influencer something worthwhile to explore, with enough freedom to make it useful.)
Brand fit: would you be comfortable standing next to them?
It’s easy to agree with someone when they’re saying exactly what you want to hear. The more revealing question is how you feel about the rest of their work.
Read beyond the handful of posts in their proposal. Look at how they respond to criticism, how they discuss other businesses and whether their behaviour reflects the values they talk about.
You don’t need to share every opinion. Independent thinking is part of what makes someone interesting. But you do need confidence in their judgement, particularly when the conversation becomes more difficult.
And they should be asking questions about you, too. Someone who wants to understand your business, interrogate your brief and decide whether the partnership makes sense is taking their own credibility seriously.
Your brand fit checklist:
‣ Do their values, tone and behaviour sit comfortably alongside your brand?
‣ Have you checked for relevant competitor relationships, conflicts or reputational concerns?
‣ Can they collaborate constructively while retaining their own voice?
‣ Could the relationship develop beyond a single campaign? The aim is to find enough shared ground to build something both parties can stand behind.
Before you agree the partnership
One final question: what are you asking this person to help change?
Greater awareness among a particular group? A better understanding of a complex issue? Relevant registrations for an event? Conversations with potential customers?
Agree that before deciding what they should create. Then establish the practical details – deliverables, timings, fees, approvals, disclosure, usage rights and how you’ll assess the results.
A checklist can help you make a more considered decision, but it still needs human judgement. Speak to the person. Ask them about your industry. Listen to the questions they ask in return. The most revealing part of choosing a B2B influencer may be the conversation you have before anything is published.